Montreal-style, Indianapolis-baked

A Better Bagel Starts With the Bake

Find dense, chewy Montreal-style bagels with a golden finish, baked for breakfast, lunch, and sharing around Indianapolis.

Explore Our Bagels

Our services

Bagels for Every Table

Order fresh Montreal-style bagels for breakfast, brunch, office spreads, or a quick bite around Indianapolis.

Classic Bagels

A chewy center and golden crust make these bagels a satisfying everyday choice.

Seeded Bagels

Choose a savory, seed-coated bagel for added texture and flavor.

Sweet Bagels

Bring a touch of sweetness to breakfast or an afternoon snack.

Bagel Sandwiches

Make lunch more satisfying with fillings served on a fresh bagel.

Cream Cheese Spreads

Pair your bagel with a creamy spread for an easy breakfast or snack.

Bagel Catering

Bring a bagel spread to meetings, brunches, and casual gatherings.

Bagels with Montreal Roots

Circle City Bagels brings Montreal-style bagels to Indianapolis with a focus on the craft behind each bake. These bagels are known for their distinct shape, chewy texture, and lightly crisp exterior. We make them for a satisfying breakfast, an easy lunch, or a shareable addition to the table.

Our bakery gives Indianapolis neighbors a place to find freshly baked bagels and thoughtful options for enjoying them at home or on the go. Whether you have a favorite topping or want to try something new, we keep the focus on good bagels, careful preparation, and friendly service.

Craft

We honor the distinctive texture and preparation that define Montreal-style bagels.

Freshness

We focus on freshly baked bagels for everyday meals and gatherings.

Neighborly

We make it easy for Indianapolis customers to find a bagel they’ll enjoy.

Bagel Questions

What makes Montreal-style bagels different?

Montreal-style bagels are typically smaller, denser, and chewier than many other bagels, with a lightly crisp exterior. Their distinctive shape and preparation give them a character all their own.

Can I buy bagels to take home?

Yes. You can get bagels to enjoy later or share at home. Contact Circle City Bagels to ask about current availability and the best way to place an order.

Do you offer bagels for groups?

Bagels can make an easy option for a meeting, brunch, or family gathering. Get in touch with Circle City Bagels to discuss your needs and confirm available group-order options.

How should I store bagels?

Keep bagels in a sealed bag at room temperature if you plan to eat them soon. For longer storage, freeze them soon after purchase, then thaw or warm as needed.

How can I reheat a bagel?

Slice the bagel and toast it for a crisp finish, or warm it briefly in an oven. If frozen, let it thaw first or adjust the warming time to heat it through.